Magic Truffles vs Magic Mushrooms: Who will win?

Magic truffles and magic mushrooms are two well-known sources of psilocybin, a naturally occurring psychedelic compound that induces profound mind-altering effects. Although they originate from the same species of fungus, they differ in various ways, including potency, trip experience, legality, and availability.

But which one is the better choice? In this article, we’ll compare magic truffles and magic mushrooms, highlighting their key differences, benefits, and drawbacks, to help you decide which is best suited for your psychedelic journey.

A recap of magic truffles and magic mushrooms

Magic truffles and magic mushrooms are very similar, but there are distinctions between them. You may already be aware of what each is, but in case you’re not, here's a quick overview of what distinguishes truffles from shrooms.

What are magic truffles?

Magic truffles, also known as psilocybin truffles or sclerotia, are underground formations of certain fungi in the Psilocybe genus. They serve as a survival mechanism, storing nutrients to help the fungus endure harsh conditions. Like magic mushrooms, truffles contain psilocybin and psilocin, which cause psychedelic effects when ingested.

Typically, they are found in the wild or cultivated in controlled environments, which is where they’ll come from if you purchase them. Magic truffles are famous because they are sold legally in the Netherlands, where they have evaded prohibition.

What are magic mushrooms?

Magic mushrooms, or psilocybin mushrooms, are the fruiting bodies of species of fungi that produce psilocybin. The most common species is Psilocybe cubensis, which grows in different climates but can also be cultivated with relative ease.

Many magic mushroom species have been traditionally used in spiritual and shamanic rituals, and they gained popularity in Europe and the US in the psychedelic movement of the 20th century. These mushrooms remain illegal in most countries, but some regions permit them for research purposes and certain clinical uses.

Fresh Mushrooms Grow Kit 'Golden Teacher'

(1861)

(1861)

Fresh Mushrooms Grow Kit 'Golden Teacher'

View

The key differences between magic truffles and magic mushrooms

Whilst both shrooms and truffles contain the same psychoactive alkaloids, there are meaningful differences between them. The differences include potency, effects, consumption methods, legal status, and how they're grown.

Potency

Magic mushrooms generally contain higher concentrations of psilocybin compared to magic truffles. The potency varies depending on the mushroom species, with some, like Psilocybe azurescens, for example, being significantly stronger than others.

Magic truffles, on the other hand, have lower psilocybin levels, meaning larger quantities are required to achieve the same intensity of effects. However, the trip experience remains similar when dosages are adjusted accordingly.

Trip experience

Both magic mushrooms and truffles induce psychedelic effects such as altered perception, enhanced creativity, deep introspection, and euphoria. Mushrooms tend to produce more intense and longer-lasting trips due to their higher psilocybin content.

Truffles offer a milder and often more manageable experience, making them ideal for beginners or those seeking a less overwhelming journey. The effects of both can be influenced by factors such as dosage, mindset, setting, and individual sensitivity.

Consumption methods

Magic mushrooms can be consumed fresh or dried, eaten raw, brewed into tea, or infused into food and beverages. Drying mushrooms enhances their shelf life and makes dosing more consistent.

Magic truffles are typically eaten raw, though they can also be blended into tea or mixed with food to mask their earthy taste. Both forms require proper dosing to ensure a safe and controlled psychedelic experience.

Legal status

Magic mushrooms are illegal in most parts of the world, including the UK, the USA, and most of Europe. Some countries, such as Brazil and Jamaica, allow their use and sale, while others like Canada and the USA permit them for controlled research and certain therapeutic applications.

Magic truffles remain legal in the Netherlands, where they are sold in specialised shops under strict regulations. Their legality makes truffles more accessible to those looking to experience psilocybin without breaking the law.

Cultivation and availability

Magic mushrooms can be cultivated using grow kits or through more advanced techniques involving spores and substrates. Their cultivation is illegal in many countries unless authorised for research purposes.

Magic truffles, on the other hand, are grown in controlled environments and widely available in Dutch smart shops. Since they grow underground, truffles are less susceptible to contamination compared to mushrooms.

Valhalla Magic Truffles

(4620)

(4620)

Valhalla Magic Truffles

View

Magic truffles vs magic mushrooms

Framing it as a competition misses the point—there are specific pros and cons to both shrooms and truffles, but neither really outperforms the other. Generally, those who try shrooms will prefer them to truffles due to their potency, effects, and the fact that they are easier on the stomach. That said, truffles are easier to get hold of and can be better for beginners.

Benefits and drawbacks of magic truffles

The benefits of truffles include:

• Legal in the Netherlands, making them accessible to users in certain regions.
• Lower potency offers a gentler introduction to psychedelics, ideal for beginners.
• Easier to store and more resistant to contamination compared to mushrooms.

The drawbacks of truffles include:

• Lower psilocybin content means higher doses are needed for strong effects.
• Some users report a more physically uncomfortable come-up phase.
• Fewer strain varieties compared to magic mushrooms.
• They can have an unpleasant taste.
• They can upset the stomach due to the large doses needed for a potent trip.

Benefits and drawbacks of magic mushrooms

The benefits of shrooms include:

• Higher potency allows for a more profound psychedelic experience.
• More strain variety, each with unique characteristics.
• Traditional and historical significance in spiritual and therapeutic settings.
• They taste better than truffles.

The drawbacks of shrooms include:

• Illegal in most countries, making them difficult to access.
• More challenging to cultivate and store compared to truffles.
• Higher potency can lead to overwhelming experiences, especially for inexperienced users.

Fresh Mushrooms Grow Kit 'McKennaii'

(2612)

(2612)

Fresh Mushrooms Grow Kit 'McKennaii'

View

Which one should you choose: Magic truffles or magic mushrooms?

Whether you go for shrooms or magic truffles comes down to a variety of factors and, particularly, your preferences. Do you want a legal and convenient option, or do you prefer a more potent and intense psychedelic experience? Can you stomach anything, or do you need something gentler?

For beginners, magic truffles may be the better choice due to their lower potency and legal availability in certain countries. However, for experienced psychonauts, magic mushrooms provide a more intense and immersive psychedelic journey. If you prefer a legal and hassle-free option, magic truffles are the best choice, as they can be purchased online and shipped to many regions.

All roads lead to psilocybin

While magic truffles and magic mushrooms differ in potency, legality, and cultivation, they both offer transformative experiences through psilocybin. Whether you choose truffles or mushrooms, responsible use, proper dosing, and a safe setting are key to a meaningful psychedelic journey.

Rather than a competition, the real takeaway is that, while both offer different experiences and pros and cons, both magic mushrooms and truffles have unique value that appeals to different preferences.

Max Sargent

Max has been writing for over a decade, and has come into cannabis and psychedelic journalism in the last few years. Writing for companies such as Zamnesia, Royal Queen Seeds, Cannaconnection, Gorilla Seeds, MushMagic and more, he has experience in a broad spectrum of the industry.

Read full bio